Ocean Park house at 2071 Calle Cacique sells for $2,175,000, 10% below its asking price
The house at 2071 Calle Cacique, on a corner lot in Ocean Park's Urbanización Santa Teresita in Santurce, San Juan, sold for $2,175,000. Calle Malaga LLC bought it from Ocean Beach Living, LLC; the sale deed was recorded on August 14, 2026.
The deed describes a lot of 598 m2, zoned RT-3, which puts the price at about $3,634 per square metre of land.
Asked $2.43 million since March 2024
The house had been listed at $2,430,000 since March 2024, described as fully remodeled in 2025 with six bedrooms, six bathrooms, a private guest suite, 3,306 square feet of living space, a poolside patio and a two-car garage. An earlier listing, from August 2022, asked $2,600,000 while the house was being rebuilt. The sale closed 10.5% below the asking price, and the listing was still shown as active in October 2026.
From foreclosure to $2.175 million
The property went through a foreclosure sale in July 2016 at $1,215,000. Ocean Beach Living, LLC bought it in June 2017 for $355,648 on the tax roll's copy of the deed; the registry's copy of the same deed carries $38,250. At the tax-roll figure, the seller sold for about six times what it paid.
The seller then rebuilt the house. A construction permit in its name, filed under 2073 Calle Cacique on the same lot, was approved in February 2022 after an environmental determination in October 2021; the project's filings describe the rehabilitation of a dwelling. Before that the property operated as Tu Casa Guest House, a guest house with a restaurant, under use permits filed between 2001 and 2006, and a 2004 petition sought to rezone it from RT-3 to a commercial tourist district for that use.
The neighbouring house at 2073 Calle Cacique, also six bedrooms and fully renovated, has been listed at $2,600,000 since December 2025.
What comes next
No permit has been filed on the property since the sale; the latest filing is one approved on August 14, 2025.
House sales nearby in the past 12 months
Within 500 m of the property, 23 houses sold in the 12 months to October 22, 2026, at a median of $1,400,000; 16 of them for $1 million or more. On Calle Cacique, No. 2060 sold for $1,550,000 in March 2026, No. 2014 for $1,590,000 in November 2025, No. 2006 for $1,550,000 in December 2025 and No. 2021 for $1,467,000 in September 2026. On Calle España, one street over, No. 2007 sold for $1,940,000 in November 2025, No. 2054 for $2,100,000 in April 2026, No. 2003 for $2,200,000 in May 2026 and No. 2010 for $2,010,000 the same month.
