Puerto Rico notary says Karibe exposed property fraud, not caused it
An attorney and notary argued that Karibe, the digital platform of Puerto Rico's Property Registry, is not to blame for the property fraud that recent investigations exposed, and called for basic registry controls and connected government records instead, in an opinion column Microjuris al Día published on November 20, 2026 (aldia.microjuris.com).
Why the column defends Karibe
The column responds to investigations by the Centro de Periodismo Investigativo and Rayos X into public land and private properties allegedly taken through falsified certifications and public deeds that the Property Registry later recorded. Much of the public criticism since then has fallen on notaries, the author wrote.
Several notaries have in turn criticized Karibe, the column noted, arguing that its open access to documents could be used to copy signatures, reproduce notarial seals or even forge deeds. The author, who is also a master's student in notarial and property registry law, called that a confusion of the symptom with the problem: the weakness, in her view, lies in the notarial and registry systems.
She credited the platform with making the scheme visible. Without the access Karibe provides, she wrote, journalists could not have examined thousands of transactions, spotted the patterns or shown how land that belongs to everyone was taken. Limiting that access will not stop the next fraud, the column argued.
Gaps the author wants closed
The column separates two cases: state land transferred by certification, and private properties transferred by public deeds authorized by notaries, some of them since deceased and others who say in court they were deceived about who was signing. On the state land, it asks how anyone found such specific registry details on old properties with no recent registry activity.
Under current law, the author wrote, a deed can be presented to the registry after the notary who authorized it has died, because presenting a deed is voluntary. She suggested making presentation mandatory within a short period after signing, and letting only the authorizing notary present it. Before recording any document, she wrote, the registry should at least verify that the notary was alive and allowed to practice on the signing date.
Her main concern is that Puerto Rico's registries do not talk to each other. ODIN, the office that issues certificates that a power of attorney is still valid, is not connected to the Demographic Registry, so it keeps issuing them after the person who granted the power has died, even though death ends it. In practice, she wrote, a dead owner can sell a property through an agent.
The author pointed to Estonia, Chile and Costa Rica as countries that brought notaries and property registries into the digital era. She urged lawmakers to update the law for qualified digital signatures, secure platforms for remote authentication, biometric identification and blockchain, and said none of it will be enough unless the Demographic Registry, ODIN and the Property Registry can share information.
What land is listed at across the island
Land is much of what the investigations describe changing hands. On the market today, sellers are advertising 4,629 land properties for sale across Puerto Rico, at a median asking price of $179,000, a figure that reflects what sellers want and not what buyers paid.