Bills target forged titles after $68,000 Guayama deed Housing disowns
Lawmakers and the head of Puerto Rico's notaries' association are preparing bills to stop forged titles from reaching the Property Registry, after an investigation found a deed the Department of Housing says it never signed was used in court to remove a fisherman from coastal land in Guayama's Barrio Jobos, Sin Comillas reported on November 16, 2026, publishing the work of the Centro de Periodismo Investigativo and Rayos X.
A deed nobody signed
A man who swore he owned 1.78 cuerdas of land on the Guayama coast sued the fisherman for using the lot without a lease. In September 2025, the Guayama Court of First Instance ordered the fisherman to tear down a wooden shack he had built there, the outlet reported.
The plaintiff says the department sold him the land for $68,000 by public deed in 2006. The investigation found that deed is missing from the index of the notary who supposedly authorized it, and the department told the reporters it made no such transaction. The former official named as signing for the agency said he never appeared before that notary, that the Social Security number attributed to him is wrong and that he never held the post the deed gives him.
The deed was still recorded. A registry certification, which courts accept as evidence, was filed with the lawsuit. Nobody caught the forgery because any document bearing a notary's signature and seal is presumed true and correct, the outlet reported. The investigators also found a Santurce property recorded through a 2006 deed signed by a notary who had been suspended since May 2005.
What lawmakers and notaries propose
A senator from the Puerto Rican Independence Party said she is drafting a bill to end certifications as a way to transfer title, along with a resolution to investigate the irregularities. Since 1977 the department has been allowed to grant titles by certification, documents that neither buyers nor notaries sign, to serve more than 16,000 people occupying lots.
The president of the Colegio Notarial de Puerto Rico said certifications "should not exist." He plans a bill so that a deed presented to the registry three or five years after it was signed needs a certification from the Office of Inspection of Notaries confirming it is in the notary's records. Another senator said he will file a resolution to inventory the department's properties.
The registry's administrative director said the registry "neither gives nor takes away rights," and that recording a void deed does not make it valid. Registrars cannot investigate or annul documents. This year they have made about seven referrals to district prosecutors, though he did not say whether any concerned fraud.
A system built on trust
Puerto Rico has about 8,300 notaries. The notaries' inspection office has 24 inspectors, who check the form of a deed, such as its signatures, number, date and place, the outlet reported.
Lawyers quoted in the investigation pointed to Law 216-2010, which treated as recorded the documents presented up to April 30, 2010, to clear a backlog. The fiscal oversight board reported a backlog of 480,000 notarial documents in 2018 and 2019.
On November 17, 2026, 39 land properties in Guayama were listed for sale, at a median asking price of $295,000. The town's land market is at the Guayama land market profile.